And even more MITB feedback

Thumbs up. WAY UP.

Hot crowd tonight at Ye Locale WWE Bar. I got there a half hour before the show started, the normal room they open for shows was completely full, and they were hopelessly shortstaffed due to the overflow crowd (which they ultimately had to open a second room for). These were the hardcore passionate fans - they either loved John Cena or they loved CM Punk and it was a lot closer to 50/50 than the crowd was in Chicago. Had an amazing conversation with the youngster next to me who thought SOME of it was fake, but he believed the main event was totally real and that these two guys both wanted to be the best and whoever had the title was the best. YES, A TITLE MATTERED. Punk and Cena certainly wrestled that match like it did, so even if the rest of the show had been a dud the ****+ main event would have sent me home happy. Other than Kelly Kelly vs. The Bella (don't know which one and don't care) nothing was bad. I thought Daniel Bryan winning was a nice surprise, and the better match of the two MITB (second best match overall behind Punk and Cena) but it was good to see Del Rio win and know they haven't given up on his push just yet. When you have a hot crowd full of enthusiastic fans even a mediocre show can seem good, but I think if I had ordered this one at home I would have been just as happy. Kudos to WWE for putting Mark Henry over strong too since Big Show is popular enough to give him the rub and not be hurt by it, especially since they seem to be giving Henry the serious monster heel push they do now and then (but this one seems much better and more relevant than when he was ECW Champion). So in short, best match Punk vs. Cena, second best the MITB which Daniel Bryan won, and the obvious worst match was for the WWE Butterfly Belt. They need to change that belt more than Cena's.

- Steve Juon (Stevie J)

Thumbs Way Up

Best Match: Cm Punk vs. John Cena (duh)
Worst Match: Kelly Kelly vs. The Bella girl (probably a good thing it's the worst match)
Today was a special day for me. As an adult and somewhat cindical wrestling fan there have only been a few markout moment for me in the post kayfabe era
Shawn Michaels at SummerSlam '02
Eddie Guerrero's Title Win in '04
Chris Benoit's Title Win in '04
Bret Hart's Return in '10
CM Punk's Title Win in '11
There's something about the underdog story that will always be the best storyline in wrestling. Cm Punk vs. John Cena delivered and in a major way. For all CM Punk's accomplishments, you'll be hard pressed to find his list of 4 star matches in the WWE. Is this a 5 star match? To some, it was. To me, it was. This is my first non Wresltemania non Royal Rumble PPV since Vengeance '06, and CM Punk was the reason. Whenever the WWE has buzz for a show, it's important that they have a great show to keep new fans coming back. Tonight they did what needed to be done. Both the Money in the Bank matches were excellent. There were creative spots and hopefully no one got injured too badly. The Christian vs. Orton match was good, and most importantly gave them a reason to keep messing around on Smackdown until they can figure the next feud. Of course the only reason this show isn't another PPV is because of CM Punk. The Chicago crowd was super hot, and hopefully the WWE realized that a hometown hero isn't a bad thing. CM Punk worked the crowd perfectly. Most importantly, after Punk wins and leaves with the title, who isn't turning on Raw to find out where this storyline goes next. As always WWE is an abusive lover who makes you want to leave them forever, but then they show that ray of light and give you everything you've ever wanted in a wrestling promotion. Hopefully, this is the start of a new day. Unfortunately, like an abusive lover, it might go back to normal in 2 weeks.

-Troy Cummings

Thumbs Up
Best Match: Punk/Cena
Worst Match: Kelly vs. Bella
This was my first WWE pay per view in 4 years and it was worth every penny.
Smackdown MITB was the 2nd best match on the show behind the main event. Very exciting and enjoyed watching Daniel Bryan win it. 3 3/4 stars
Kelly vs. Brie. Nothing to say. Bad match 1/2 star
Big Show vs. Mark Henry was fine. Just two big guys hitting each other. Post match was better than the actual match. 2 1/4 stars
Raw MITB was fun. Scared that Miz hurt himself badly only to get a babyface pop when he limped out. Del Rio seemed like the obvious choice. 3 1/2 stars
Christian and Orton was very disappointing. Seemed like a tv match with a stupid stipulation. 2 stars
Cena vs. Punk. The ovation for Punk was amazing. Couldn't hear this music the crowd was so loud. They had a great match with a great finish. 4 1/2 stars
Josh Hayes

Two thumbs up.
Y'know ... feedback like this is what you get when you decide to target 28-year-olds instead of 8-year-olds, but don't worry, Vince -- we'll buy plenty of ice cream bars.
Hoping they don't screw this up tomorrow night. (But then again, who am I kidding?)
And was it just me, or did Miz's knee look pretty gnarly?
Chris Strub
Binghamton, NY

Thumbs way up.

Best match: Cena vs Punk
Worst match: Divas title (by default)

What an amazing PPV, the best I've seen from WWE for a long time. This really showed the disillusioned fans why they've stuck with WWE for so long and this has finally made me proud to say that I'm a wrestling fan again. Really had a sense of excitement that has been missing for so long, and the crowd was jacked the entire night. Just shows what proper build can do for a PPV and CM Punk was booked perfectly for his hometown return and it showed with crowd reactions throughout the night.

The two ladder matches were both great with the Smackdown one being my personal favourite although Bourne's shooting star press was jaw dropping. Was great (and unexpected) to see Bryan win. The Divas title match and Show/Henry were fine and Christian/Orton was a good match but I was tuning in for the main event and it didn't dissapoint. The crowd was off the charts and the match, although it had a couple of blown spots at times, is probably WWE match of the year. The emotion was incredible and it threw every curve ball going. Really thought they were going with the Survivor Series 97 ending and when they swerved it again it just made it even better. Hopefully Punk is staying around for a while because it looks like WWE have finally found the best anti-hero champion since Stone Cold (I truly believe that).

Just a fantastic night to be a wrestling fan.

Tony Fleming


I wasn’t planning on buying this PPV, but your ongoing report was so positive that I felt compelled to purchase the replay. I’m glad I did.

A MASSIVE THUMBS UP for the ending of the main event alone!

This is exactly how I wanted the show to end – with Punk’s hand raised and having outwitted Vince. Great booking (let’s see how they screw it up on RAW, though).

As for the rest of the card, everyone I wanted to win, won. I’m a happy camper tonight.

Best match: Punk vs Cena

Worst match: women’s match

Let’s hope WWE don’t botch up this angle from here.


Dann Lennard

Sydney, Australia

Thumbs way up.

Best mach - Punk vs. Cena

Worst match - Kelly vs. Bella

I never miss a show but I haven't felt compelled to send in feedback for a long time now.  This show really deserves acknowledgement though.  Except for the women, this was a tremendous show.  I was shocked and somewhat elated that Danielson won. Happy that Del Rio won and overjoyed to see Punk actually leave the building with the title.  I genuinely can't wait to see where they go with this.  It actually reminded me of being a kid and the excitement I would feel watching wrestling back then.  A really great PPV. 

Chris Hodgson

Thumbs Way Up

Best Match: C.M. Punk vs John Cena

Worst Match: Kelly Kelly vs Brie Bella

First bought PPV since Royal Rumble ( I was at WM) and the best 'B' PPV show since One Night Stand !

Loved the ending of the show and will be fascinating to see where WWE goes from here.

Edwin Guerra Jr.

Money in the Bank

Thumbs Up

Best Match: Punk v Cena

Worst Match: Divas

Now that WWE is intent on building SummerSlam into a BIG event, that means they need a strong set-up show that puts everything in motion.
For that reason, more thought went into MITB than any regular B show. And the show delivered big.

If you can forget that they are building MARK HENRY again, for a main event run. And Kelly Kelly is the pointless Divas champion in a division running in place.

Based on some of the things set in motion, Daniel Bryan is scheduled to become the first person to cash in and lose his MITB opportunity. And Alberto Del Rio builds steam as the man for whom the big title is just out of his grasp.

CM Punk was over huge. Now they just need to capitalize while - and if - he is away.

It's hard to have two Superman like Orton and Cena and keep them protected on the same show. But they found two ways to do it and stay fresh.

Jeff Cohen
Flushing, NY

Thumbs UP
Best Match: Cena vs. Punk
Worst Match: Kelly Kelly vs. Brie Bella
Total thumbs up show last night. 
Both of the Money in the Bank matches were great, the Orton and Christian match was also good and the Mark Henry match served its purpose of getting Henry over as a top heel.
The main event was phenomenal.  Goes to show what a hot crowd can do for a match.  
Patrick McHugh


A buddy of mine split the PPV and it's the 1st PPV I've seen since going to Elimination Chamber live. The last PPV a purchased prior to that was WrestleMania 2010. I actively wanted do my (very) small part to increase the buy-rate for this show.

Thumbs Up!

Best Match: Punk v. Cena

Worst Match: Divas ....although to be honest, we changed the channel to watch some of the BoSox-Rays game.

I thought it was terrible to book Miz like a babyface in MITB, but aside from that both MITB matches were fun for what they were; especially the SmackDown one. Glad to see  Christian win the title. Very glad to see Bryan win. That said, the thing I cared about most, the reason why I bought the PPV, was Punk and that match and the booking was fantastic.

-Jonathan Sarpolis
doc_sarp on The Board
Alameda, CA

Thumbs up.

Best match: Cena vs Punk

Worst match: Divas title.

Ill keep it short as Im sure everything has been said already. Two awesome ladder matches, two nothing buffer matches, another good Christian v Orton match and a phenomenal main with the right finish made this show truly unforgettable. An amazing moment as a fan. 

Barry Murphy

Thumbs Way Up

Best Match ;  Punk-Cena

Worst match:  Diva title match

Perfect PPV.  Chicago crowd just makes great ppv’s even better.  Love my hometown!!  Well, we’ll see where Vince takes it from here.  As a lifelong fan and seeing WWE screw up most money making angles I’m praying they don’t “f” this up.  But I’m along for the ride.


Scott Lennartson

Elgin, IL

Thumbs Up

Best: Cena-Punk
Worst: Divas

I haven't purchased a WWE PPV since 2010 Wrestlemania and I'm glad I purchased this one. As I mentioned on my Twitter and Facebook, a show (and angle) like Punk's is the reason I've been sticking with professional wrestling throughout these several lean years. Great match, great execution and I'm excited to see where they go from here.

Matt Holmes
Indianapolis, Ind.

Thumbs Up
Best Match: Punk/Cena
Worst Match:Kelly Kelly/ Brie Bella
I'll be short. Daniel Bryan won MITB. CM Punk took the belt with him. We had 11 people over for the PPV (and 3 more called today to watch it on DVR). 
Not since Rock/Austin I have we had near that amount. The crowd in Chicago was great. Everyone here loved the show. I know a bunch of people will be watching raw tonight that don't normally watch. Good for WWE for keeping this interesting. I hope they run with this momentum. 
Chris Stein
New York

At this point I am just mirroring what has already been stated by everybody so far, but this was one of the greatest ppv's I have ever seen.  Last year's show was excellent, and this raised the bar to an almost unreachable level.  It's like in one night, WWE decided to stop messing around and get their act together.  I haven't been as into a wrestling show as I was for this show since the initial One Night Stand ppv.  Tonight reminded me why I didn't flee from wrestling like all the fair-weather fans did over the past decade.  Incredible matches, storylines, and intrigue made this the perfect ppv. 
I haven't ordered any WWE ppv's consistently since the early 2000's due to the cost and lack of other people to chip in money, but over the past handful of months I have ordered Wrestlemania and Money in the Bank, and I attended Capitol Punishment.  Not only that, but friends that were once fans, now casual fans, or never fans before, are starting to get into wrestling.  I think if WWE continues to deliver intriguing storylines and matches like this there is nowhere to go but up. 
Best match: Punk vs. Cena
Worst match: Women's match
Thumbs all the way up.
Matt Wright

Who is the strongest of these Hall of Fame candidates?


What do you believe is the second most popular promotion right now in the U.S?