It took until after the show started, but the storyline of Flip Gordon getting booked for All In finally came to an end as part of the Over Budget Battle Royale.
Gordon won the battle royal after dressing up as Chico El Luchador. The story for the match was that Gordon was powerbombed through a table outside the ring by Bully Ray as it started. He sold on the outside until Bully Ray eliminated Colt Cabana and appeared to have the match won. Gordon came into the ring, superkicked Bully Ray, unmasked, and threw him out.
Gordon and Bully Ray have also been involved in a feud for Ring of Honor.
Gordon will challenge for Jay Lethal's ROH World Championship on the All In main card.
Moose, Brandon Cutler, Trent Barreta, Chuck Taylor, Rocky Romero, Cheeseburger, Shane "Hurricane" Helms, Ethan Page, Tommy Dreamer, Jimmy Jacobs, Punishment Martinez, Austin Gunn, Billy Gunn, Marko Stunt, Brian Cage, Jordynne Grace, Cabana, Bully Ray, and Gordon were the participants in the battle royal.